ok ive been saving this rant for aw hile now after reading all those atlantis threads. so this is kind of also directed at all the people who have posted stuff on those threads, and are just waiting to post the same stuff on here.
i think just like all shows, atlantis needs time. their cast hasnt even clicked yet, or know eachother that well. for people who seem to have an issue with the lack of military feel, i dont get why its required. if you want them operating off a military base, why even watch the off-shoot program. stick to stargate and beg them not to end it ever because if they kept that 'off the miltary base' thing they might as well not have created the new show. also, they've kept quite alot of the militaryness into it. i dont mind it turning more into a scifi show, because it seems about the same when it comes to technology problems in episode plots. whenever theres tech-babble in stargate sg1, dont act like it makes perfect sense to you, so dont complain when at the end of every atlantis episode stuff magically ends up making sense as well. because thats just how the episode-based shows are. you have to have a resolution. on earth, we have carter, who just because shes sitting on earth, can come up with a solution using alien technology and viewers wont mind. yet when mckay does it using alien (ancient) technology in another galaxy, its "OMQ TOO SCIFI LIKE WORMHOLE X-TREME!!". its a new show and its doing really well for the first season. just coz its got the same creaters and same crew does not mean it'll be up to par iwth sg1 any time soon, or in my opinion ever. im far too attached with sg1. if youre going to start picking apart the realism of atlantis vs. sg1, answer me this bout realism: why does evreyone speak english! and ....like an american for the most part.
exactly. it cant be completely realistic. so get used to the perfect advanced tech-solutions and what not. stargate was a good show not because of the actual scifi aspect of it, but because of its story and characters, and thats how i look atlantis. how well is the story going for a show that isnt even at half season of its first season yet, and how well are the characters coming along. can i hear a quote and say 'thats distinctly sheppard' or 'thats something ford would say' etc... and on a happy note im totally impressed wiht how from sg1 to atlantis, they moved the atlantis music over, and when they played the atlantis intro theme for the first time it didnt feel like a new awkward piece of music at all. i loved it.
ps. i heart both my stargates
and i like the fact that sheppard is funny. not o'neil funny (coz hes not o'neil), but funny. RDA just basically took his real life personality and slowly morfed oniel into that. he even admits it. and in his case, it worked out coz hes hilarious.
oh and as for the show not being as funny. it will get funny! if ou actually watch stargate, you'll realize a lot of their jokes are funny if you know alot of the shows history, or how the characters are. like teal'c jokes about his eyebrow raisey thing. people in atlatnis havent even eben around long enough to have any 'thing' that they do. so wait around a descent time, then get so technical about the criticism.
</rant>