hard choice, but I say painkiller for fun value. just by like, .1% though

Doom 3 > you

I like them both. Painkiller is very similar to the original Doom, I think. Doom 3 has a better story (Painkiller's story felt too much like an afterthought) and is more immersive.

Any poll that has options not relating to the question at hand (especially idiotic ones) is completely pointless and flawed.

I like Painkiller more. Painkiller claimed it would give us senseless killing...it delivered, and the graphics are AMAZING. Doom3 claimed it would look amazing, be scary as hell, and fun. In my opinion, it failed. The game was way to dark and when it was bright... (OMG PLASTIC LOL!?) The models even if they ARE very high-poly, they look so low poly. But that doesn't matter, gameplay is what matters. Gameplay was a predictable-boring-scripted-mess-of-a-thing. For some reason shooting demons with a stakegun never gets boring, but shooting demons with a larger variety of guns gets old quick...weird. Plus Painkiller had an awesome soundtrack. Both had crap multiplayer

Hmmm. I like the painkiller more than the stake gun. Specially with it's secret attack spin the blade then launch it with the alt fire. Ever wanted to catapault a spinning weed whacker at someone? Yeah.

Neopets obviously wins

*high five*

Non-sensical third poll options that everyone will choose > you.

Other than both being FPS games and fighting the hoards of Hell, I won't really compare them.

Easiest choice I have ever made. Painkiller was far more fun. I mean, I loved Doom 3, and it was everything I expected, but Painkiller came out of nowhere and kicked pant.

Neopets > Doom 3 > Painkiller > You

I own neither game, so I voted for the comedy option.

I haven't played Painkiller so I can't really compare it to Doom 3.