Mort-Hog
If moral relativism is wrong, I don't wanna be right.
Posts: 4,192
Seems like unnecessary amount of fuss just to stop the cat from bringing stuff in.
It tends to be quite difficult to get something that is very much alive through a catflap, when the door is closed, so the only creatures that are brought in through the catflap are either mortally wounded, or considerably less mobile, with various broken limbs. The cat brings them in so she can toy with them, but they don't get far and they're not a problem.
The problem that might arise is if the cat doesn't kill the creature. When it's especially warm in the summer, we tend to leave the back door open, this makes the house much cooler. But this does mean that the cat can pull in stuff that is very much alive and we end up with birds flying around the kitchen or mice hiding under the fridge. That is a problem.
But the whole 'bringing stuff in' thing is important to the cat, especially for neutered cats, as it reinforces the instinctive 'hunter role' in them providing for their family (if they don't have kittens, then you the owner will end up taking the role as her kittens!)
This seems to be another initiative in trying to stop the cat from hunting just because it seems 'cruel' or 'messy' to you, and that's very unhealthy for the cat.
"The trouble with the world is that the stupid are cocksure and the intelligent are full of doubt. " - Bertrand Russell
The Triumph of Stupidity in Mortals and Others 1931-1935