TheRuleofThirds
2 cents? Sorry, my thoughts are a buck a piece.
Posts: 190
Are you talking about a Section 31 movie?
Generations was a well-made movie, but it was blah. So were Insurrection and Nemesis. First Contact, IMO, was the first real TNG movie.
I think a new TNG movie would be good, just as long as it goes out with a bang, with a solid script. I think TNG, the show, is one of the best examples of screenwriting there is. First Contact shows the same kind of great writing that some of the episodes had. Nemesis was really disappointing because it didn't have that kind of writing, even though John Logan (Gladiator, The Aviator) wrote it. I pretty much blame Stu Baird. Of course, since Braga and Berman have been behind a lot of other Trek flops, I could certainly find grounds to blame them, too.
A new cast wouldn't be a good idea. Star Trek movies only work if you've been through a lot of small screen adventures with the cast.
DISCLAIMER: This is just armchair observation, not the result of many hours of deliberate study of the subject. I'm by no means an expert, but just an ignorant hick who's putting his two cents in. For that and a nickel, you can have a cup of coffee.