homeschooling's sucess can depend on the person, but from what I know, I do have some arguments against it. First of all, I know what a lot of you guys say, but I really do think that it's very important to your social development. most of my friendships became so tight because I saw them day in and day out and allowed them to grow. I was in a similar social situation, so I could relate to them and/or thier problems in a way I probably wouldn't have had I been homeschooled. excuse me if I go on the vein for a while, but I think, sad as it may be, social skills are some of the most important skills in society, arguably moreso than academic knowledge. Learning how to play the game, understanding the people around you, etc... School becomes your society and you can learn a whole lot from that. You also learn to work with people more, whether you're working on stupid group assignments or in musical/athletic groups.
It also opens up so many more experiences for you so that you can experiment and learn what you like and what you're good at. I've always liked music, but it became my passion in high school because of the people I was involved in it with and their excitement, I learned about as much from them as I did from my teachers and directors. You get to learn from different teachers in different settings, all of which affect you differently - Had I never had Mr Ellenberger or taken a higher level history class I would never have become interested in history or Art History. I know what environment works best for me now and how I learn, and moreover, how to adapt when I'm not taught in the style that works best for me.
that being said - homeschooling has a lot of excellent benefits and it's possible that you do learn and understand more of the material in that way. It seriously depends on the person. what I think would probably be best is a combination where the person starts out being homeschooled but still goes to a highschool for at least a period of time.
Fincham: Where are you going?
Me: I have no idea
Fincham: I meant where are you sitting. This wasn't an existential question.