I can actually stand with Nintendo on this one. They seem to be trying to make SSB:Brawl actually fun, as opposed to the greater festivals of internet douchebagery that most online games end up being.
Without score charts or records people might actually realize that the purpose of the game is to just sit back and have a good time, instead of obsessing about Winning at all costs.
The same goes for not showing player names. I dose not matter how good you are, or how much of a jerk you can be, everyone will forget you by the time the next game starts, so your superstar players and jerks all will hopefully just loose interest.
As for voice chat, I have never approved of voice chat. Tribes and Allegiance have shown that a limited voice chat menu is more that sufficient for even complicated gameplay, and SSB:Brawl doesn't even need that. The ONLY thing voice chat will be used for in SSB:Brawl is so that some 12 year old can ***** and moan about how unfair it is to just spam So-and-So's attack, and that if they would fight "fair" he would kick their ***. And you know what, GOOD RIDDANCE.
I'm not saying Nintendo's strategy will work, but I whole heartedly approve with what they are trying here, and am also very surprised that they are trying something this big with a game that it at the very core of the Wii Linup.
"Well, if I am not drunk, I am mad, but I trust I can behave like a gentleman in either
condition."... G. K. Chesterton
“questions are a burden to others; answers a prison for oneself”