A good, firm handshake with eye contact is always better than a limp one with no eye contact. No one can really deny that.
I think Mort-Hog is getting riled up because most of you seem to believe things like a good handshake and personality are "REALLY IMPORTANT" i.e. placing it above credentials in terms of importance. For example...
etc etc...
For getting a respectable job, credentials are EVERYTHING. Everyone coming into that room for the interview, unless they are completely retarded, will by default have a good handshake and try to project positive energy. I haven't met a single educated person familiar with Western culture who had a bad handshake since the end of high school. Thus, the only way to distinguish yourself at that point is with your credentials. I don't deny that being personable and having a good handshake are important. However, it's extremely easy to pull off a decent handshake, so if you think about it, it's very naive to be judging someone based on it anyway. It's like saying having decent hair is important. Everyone can make their hair look decent and presentable, and no one's going to give a decent job to someone who comes in sporting a neon green mohawk... but who the **** goes into an interview with a mohawk?
Secondly, as for personality, it's really only important during your employment and if you want to move up the corporate hierarchy. Even then it's really more about your job performance than anything else, unless you guys are talking about low-level blue collar jobs (but I don't give two ****s about those). Do you know how many upper-level management people are considered conceited overbearing pricks?
Thirdly, credentials mean a lot. Everyone I know who has great credentials (very high GPA, good school, active in various organizations, sports, etc) has been personable, helpful, smart, and hardworking. The numbers rarely lie, and if they do, it's the exception to the rule. I have a couple friends at MIT and Caltech who approach everything in their life with as much vigor as they do with their studies. People who fail at school usually fail at other aspects in life. The cum laudes of my graduating class went on to get great jobs or fellowships, EASILY. The ones who got Bs and Cs? Yeah, they're easy-going and fun to hang out with. They probably have good handshakes, heh. Anyway, they ended up getting jobs at decent consulting firms, surprisingly. Had they gone to a State University of Bum**** Nowhere, I'm pretty sure they would be living in their parents' basements right now.
If a "good handshake" and "great personality" are the only things on your resume, I'm sorry.