Recusant
Prefered by 80% of Doctors
Posts: 1,480
So if you can excuse Christianity from the actions of the holocaust because the Nazis weren't "acting with good, wholesome, Christian values as their motivation" then why not excuse Islam from the actions of insurgents kidnapping, torturing and executing people? After all they don't have good, wholesome Islamic values as their motivation? Frankly I believe both religions play their part respectively and deserve some of the blame.
To point out some of the other things Christianity has helped with in the past century, a rather obvious one is apartheid in S Africa. The treatment of blacks was frequently justified in the Dutch Reformed Church by claiming they bore the curse of Ham/Canaan and that the story of Babel was part of God's will that the races be separate. The majority Afrikaner part of the white population felt that they were God's chosen people drawing comparisons between the voortrekker period (where the Boers trekked out into the interior to escape the British and fought off the various tribes en route) and the Biblical exodus. They had a national holiday based on the massacre/battle at Blood River which they held to be affirmation that God was protecting them. This meant that there were plenty of Afrikaners during the apartheid years who felt no moral harm in abusing any non-white. It allowed policemen to brutally torture people, it allowed soldiers to beat and shoot protesters, it allowed the average person to ignore the conditions in which black people were living, it allowed a system of oppression to appear righteous in their eyes.
Just now you've complained about an appeal to authority but you're making the same fallacy here: "Hurrr I won't address your argument or tell you why you're wrong, I'll just call you ignorant!"
Strewth! So if I found the appropriate religion that said something ridiculous and/or terrible, you would respect me making moral judgements based off of that!? You know you can make moral judgements without necessarily being emotional about it or taking old books to contain absolute truths, right?