Meh, sorry for resurrecting an old thread, but I haven't been on in quite a while, and wanted to voice my opinion.
I really enjoyed the comic and the movie.
The movie seemed like a very abbreviated version of the comic, and sometimes the music took away from the scenes. (ride of the Valkyries) that scene would have been a lot cooler if they used different music. Made it seem silly.
Other than that, it was amazing. I hate the stupid complaints people have about it like "why does roarshach talk like batman" (I mean when you look at the word bubbles in the comic, what did you expect he would sound like!? I thought his voice was PERFECT)
And "needed less Dr. Manhattan penis" (as if it was a character of it's own, shown in close up shots. It was never focused on, just showed up when there was a wide enough shot used for you to see it. Most of the time they used close ups on him, or shots so far away you can't see it. This is the biggest complaint about this movie, and even people who refuse to watch it cause it shows a penis. I think that's really stupid. It's not made to be sexual, and appears as in many biology books and classical art. People need to grow up and stop acting like it's the first time they've seen one. Almost every review I read about watchmen talks about it and how aweful it is. One reviewer said he heard all the fuss about it, so he actually timed the scenes where you can see it, and it added up to about 1 minute and 30 seconds of footage. And with a 2:30 hour movie, that's not a huge deal.)