A. You weren't here when it started.
B. Massassi was started in the late 90s.
C. That's how you view it, because you feel threatened by any sort of criticism. You believe it's only Massassi that's like this, but truth is, Massassi's the only place you've gotten real feedback from in the first place, thus you have nothing to compare to.
D. Yes, Massassians only care about looks. That's why the Rolling Mod was a complete flop. Wait, what?
E. It's that sort of "I don't give a damn" attitude that makes it obvious you can't handle criticism.
F. It's not unfair to assume that something made in a game engine of today would at least look like it was in the game made today.
G. Because you know, everyone is like Ruthven (No offense Ruthven!) and spends ages making their levels. No one has released a good looking level for JK on Massassi because they took so long that Massassi "died" before it was finished. Wait, what?
H. If it was intended to be like the original Oasis as much as possible, why add things like trees and such which have absolutely no gameplay explanation? Prooobably because you wanted it to look better, but you didn't go beyond throwing a few models around.
I. Hint: You're talking about all Massassians when you say that "Massassi forums is run by a bunch of 12 year olds". None of the people you even had a problem with actually moderate/run this forum in any way shape or form. And in fact, one of the people you had a problem with made nothing more than a regular comment which you exploded into this tirade the whole time about.
You have a problem with criticism.
I rest my case.