I'm going to get it so I can play with the game with my 4 year old brother over the summer.
My brother loves all the Portal 2 videos, promotions and gameplay. The "blue paint" and the "orange paint". He likes the sounds of the turrets when they shoot and fall over, the new red lasers, and the pneumatic tube when sucking things up. And he also likes the 2 robot guys, calls them "blue eye" and "orange eye."
Last game I bought for us together was Super Mario Galaxy 2, and we had a blast playing together, despite it being a shameless derivative of the first. It was colorful, the levels are simple enough for him to understand (despite the gravity), and the bad guys are recognizable. I can still see why the criticisms of the game are valid, but, for those brief moments in time about year ago, it didn't matter.
Really, I don't buy many new games anymore, and I guess when I do buy one, it would probably be for both of us.
SnailIracing:n(500tpostshpereline)pants
-----------------------------@%