I have been hesitant to comment much about the operation in general until it had time to sink in and more details were available. As I've taken in more and had the time to think about it I've come to a conclusion. This operation was all but an utter failure.
Now, don't take my opinion in anyway to disparage those involved in the authorization, leadership, or conduct of the operation. I'm not alleging anybody did anything wrong, per se, just that things went extremely wrong.
One of the most important lessons I've learned dealing with compiling information is that when the reports don't mesh, don't make sense, you are either missing details or part or all of the story is BS. I was quite taken aback by all of the conflicting statements and reports coming from the government on this operation. I was thinking, this is the single biggest event in the War on Terror and a huge symbolic victory. Why can't we get the story straight? At first it seemed like sheer incompetence on the part of the administration. The handling of the aftermath, not the operation.
So it took me a few days to look for the picture of the helicopter remains that I heard of. A few days after that my inner aviation nerd started to surface so last night I searched for more information and some more today. That's when it hit me. We shouldn't know about any of this. It's why the stories were all effed up.
Now I don't know if it was a kill mission or a capture mission or a kill or capture mission. I would hope the emphasis was on capture but, regardless, the entire thing was compromised as soon as the chopper was damaged. Surely the operation would still be unknown to this day had that not happened. Think about it, with or without Osama alive there certainly was actionable intelligence discovered there. But with significant wreckage outside the compound and a huge explosion within, the US operation was undeniable and extremely visible. Every terrorist that might have been found is on alert and relations with Pakistan are extremely strained.
To be clear, I'm no saying we failed. I'm just saying that rather than morbid celebrations in the streets of the states there should have been follow on covert operations conducted by
DEVGRU and
ACE
"I would rather claim to be an uneducated man than be mal-educated and claim to be otherwise." - Wookie 03:16