Whoops, totally forgot to respond.
A Rush Of Blood To The Head is also my favorite Coldplay album, but the fight between X&Y and Parachutes I'm still unsure about. Having finished listening to the whole album, I really really enjoyed X&Y. I enjoyed how they mixed a few different styles (Fix You, Talk, Twisted Logic), however I felt like the album as a whole was kind of....aimless, I guess. Like you said, some of the songs felt like they were meant for other albums, but wern't used and then just thrown into X&Y, and the arrangement of songs sometimes didn't seem to fit to me. Also, whenever I listen to it again, I tend to not listen to the album all the way through as a whole, jump to this song, then to this song, then back to another song, ect.
But some of the songs by themselves...
Fix You was amazingly beautiful.
The Muse-esqe Twisted Logic was great.
Swallowed In The Sea is one of my favorite songs on the album.
Speed Of Sound has an awesome sound.
I really like Talk. Alot.
So I guess overall, the flow of the album didn't feel right to me, but thats all getting a little technical, right? In the end I really enjoyed the album, it's also one of my favorite albums I got this year, and don't regret the purchase at all. Can't wait for their next album.
The tired anthem of a loser and a hypocrite.