Hmm, I think there's some miscommunication here. Let's see if I can clarify.
First, I've actually been running under the assumption that Thand
was the first human in the world of NeS. My original concerns when you first suggested it was that it would carry too many religious overtones, but I figured so long as Thand was actually a combination of various origin myths (plus our own twist), that it wouldn't be a problem. The "I hate snakes" parody joke would be pretty arbitrary otherwise.
Second, I entirely understand the concern of "labeling" the meta-fictional elements. I know I've indulged myself time and again with it, but I've watched enough anime where they over-explain things to death to know that subtext is a beautiful thing. The post with Thand versus the NeScholars, for instance, is something I don't intend to do again, and if anyone else thinks I'm going down the road of George Lucas, please please smack me.
However, in my last response to you, this wasn't my attempt to "objectify" things -- it was my attempt to show you that the current portrayal of Thand makes him out to be a weaker character than I think he has the potential to be. From the things you've focused on, he's at best an Adrian from Watchmen and at worst a pure monster with holier-than-thou motives. This would be the case even
if the NeS wasn't a meta-fictional type of story, but since it is, it's even MORE important that he avoid these tropes. I don't see the meta-fictional elements as being spelled-out replacement for magic in NeS (that would defeat the purpose of meta-fiction in general) but I don't see the meta-fictional elements as something that are just randomly thrown in either; the meta-fictional elements do define the world of NeS. I would never ask you or anyone else to write in a style that isn't true to you, but you have to trust me when I say I
do think about these things and (at the risk of being conceited) think of them as they're truest to the NeS and to good story-telling in general.
As for Thand's crying, let's then ask this. Ignoring everything typically "NeS" with the comedy and meta-fiction and such, why would he be so invested in keeping Geb and the others from disturbing the body of his Eve-equivalent if not out of a strong love for her? Not to suggest that emotions are the end-all/be-all, but it would seem very strange (to say the least) if, after so much effort to keep them away from her, he was all just "eh" upon being in his dead love's presence, no? As a reader, I can't say I'd really be able to identify with "he might be able to think about her" -- it may have worked for the story you mentioned, but I have a hard time seeing it working here. But I also have a hard time seeing Thand being in the right when he calls Geb and the others insects, makes some lofty predictions, and then does a lot of nothing.
Again, this is why I wanted to get the other writers involved -- as it should be anyway. The collaborative efforts I'm confident will resolve our butting of heads.
EDIT: Please, please continue to be antagonistic or mistaken for it. I thrive on communication -- silence is the worst for me. And, of course, I'd argue that the NeS isn't doing all that hot right now, but I always think that, don't I?
EDIT 2: I'd also like to defense my one post of Thand vs. the Scholars as mostly a response to actually
deter what I think has been your use of storywielding = ultimate power. We make fun of characters with ultimate powers with Ares, and overcoming characters with "ultimate power" is not only done often in NeS, but just becomes silly when more ultimate powers try trumping the last ultimate power. Thand is supposed to be wise and intelligent, not just another "I'm stronger than everyone" character. Yes, logically, ultimate knowledge can bring about ultimate power (as Al Ciao pointed out to my grudging acknowledgment), but his strength as a character should come from his ability to
think and think correctly to boot. Hence, my spelling out of conventions to show how Thand manipulates them explicitly with his thoughts and not just "does them." </defensive rant>
EDIT 3: Totally meant to also say that Ben's post with the strip tease to the audience was really funny! ^_^